Historical look at HB444 on eve of Governor's announcement

Reported by: Marisa Yamane
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 7/06/2010 6:41 am

We're on the eve of one of Governor Lingle's most highly anticipated decisions.

She has until 11:59 Tuesday morning to announce her decision on the civil unions bill.

The Governor can either veto, sign or let the bill become law without her signature.

It's a subject that has really touched the hearts and minds of everyone in Hawaii and I've given it the seriousness and consideration that it deserves.

"It's a subject that has really touched the hearts and minds of everyone in Hawaii and I've given it the seriousness and consideration that it deserves. I don't know the exact number but I think it's running 60-40 against, but as I'm going to talk about tomorrow, that isn't what helped me to make a decision on this it was really the depth of feeling on both sides. So I look forward to sharing that with everybody tomorrow," said Gov. Linda Lingle.

If the bill becomes law, same-sex couples would get the same rights as married couples.

Here's a look at what events led up to this moment.

The battle over equal rights for same sex couples goes back to the 1990's in Hawaii.

It began as a fight for same sex marriage, and last year shifted to civil unions.

In January 2009, the civil unions bill, HB 444, was introduced.

Controverisal from the start, a huge crowd showed up to testify during the first hearing on February 5, 2009.

A week later, House lawmakers passed the bill with a vote of 33 to 17, thus kicking the bill over to the Senate.

Later that month thousands of people opposed to civil unions descended on the State Capitol.

Most were church members.

"We are gathered here because we want our voices heard!" said Pastor Wayne Cordeiro, Against Civil Unions.

A few days later, on February 25, 2009, following fifteen hours of testimony, the Senate Judiciary Committee stalled the measure with a deadlock vote.

Then in May, Senators revived the bill.

But minutes later, a vote in favor of amending the bill to remove the references to marriage, stalled it for the '09 session, to be continued in January.

In January 2010 those on both sides of the issue filled the Senate gallery to watch the final stretch of the civil unions marathon.

Civil unions passed by a vote of 18 to 7 -- a veto-proof margin.

Then a week later -- hopes of civil unions supporters were crushed, when a motion to postpone the bill indefinitely passed on a voice vote.

A tough pill to swallow for supporters of civil unions.

"Office by office I want them to look us in the face and tell us why they denied us civil rights today," said Carolyn Golojuch, Supports Civil Unions.

But that didn't stop supporters, and they continued their fight to revive the bill, going door to door at the Capitol, even when the political odds appeared insurmountable.

Then on April 29, 2010, in a dramatic turn of events.

The civil unions bill was revived in the House on a motion by Rep. Oshiro and passed.

"This is a surprise very very happy today," said Alan Spector, Supports Civil Unions.

"I think this is not the end, obviously, so we're hoping to energize again," said Dennis Arakaki, Opposed to Civil Unions.

HB 444 then moved to the Governor's desk, where it's been sitting ever since.

Again, the Governor has until 11:59 Tuesday morning to announce her decision on the civil unions bill.

Share
5 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

makeachange - 7/9/2010 11:28 PM
0 Votes
alright well im a girl and with a girl.we "gay" people have the same rights as anyone els.thats just like saying black people can only sit in the back of the bus.but hey that changed.you know why?it only took one person to change all that.and we as one can change this too.its about love and GOD made love.what is the difference?man and women can love.so why cant man and man?and girl and girl?you can't be told who to love by ANYONE

GotAloha - 7/6/2010 3:54 PM
0 Votes
No rurouniere you didn't burst my bubble because God didn't want people to get divorced or have premarital sex either, or to be greedy etc. people choose that way not God. So we can conclude then that no one is perfect right ... That's why we need Jesus :)

rurouniere - 7/6/2010 1:18 PM
0 Votes
Civil Unions Right is under the law, not under the church. Besides, the church and the state separated centuries ago. You can get married through the church, and/or by law (you register to be married, right? that's man-made); they're asking to be united under the HUMAN-MADE laws. It's the greatest public display of affection, and there's nothing wrong with that, is there? If you wanna talk holy and talk about church and marriages and such, go stop premarital sex among teenagers, prostitution, and cosmetic surgery; they're desecrating the "House of God," which is our body. The church said that you're not supposed to have premarital sex! Oh, and marriages??? Anyone who's divorced by law is a sinner. Sorry to burst your bubble, but you're not supposed to be able to separate what God had united in marriage....so it's a sin to divorce your spouse through the law because you're supposed to do it through the church by ANNULMENT because you got married through the eyes of God. Being a Christian that you are, you should know this. So now humans are like God because it's ok to divorce through the law what "God had united under the church by marriage", but not to allow homosexuals to be united under the HUMAN-MADE laws? Eat that. "Marriage is sacred and is between a man and a woman..." sure I respect that. But they're not asking for that anymore; they're asking for the LAW (HUMAN law) to make it happen. Go criticize the people who went through divorce and call them sinners. They've been totally whoring themselves and are totally unfaithful because in the eyes of God, they're still married to the first person they did it with since they weren't annulled by the church. Hah! If you wanna talk about sins, go abolish everything that's enjoyable. Go burn your money...literally. Don't buy that new iPhone 4...it's just making you greedier...which is part of the 7 deadly sins. Btw, I'm Catholic. I came from a country where 90% of the people are Catholics.

GotAloha - 7/6/2010 12:24 PM
2 Votes
Marriage is holy and it is an institution made by God between a man and a woman not between persons of the same sex. I am a Christian and this fight against civil unions is to keep marriage as it was intended to be... between man and woman only. It's not about hate against gay people!! I speak for my Christian brothers and sisters and say that we just don't agree with what gay people practice because God is against it. We don't hate gay people..why should we... they are people too. God wants us to love all people and stand for the truth always.

SteveMD2 - 7/6/2010 6:27 AM
0 Votes
Its a mtter of equality and justice under the law. We went through the same thing about letting blacks marry (1867), and then allowing inter-racial marriage (1967) BTW, when Calif. ended laws against inter-racial marriage in 1948, 95% of the people were horrified. Today, more and more we are becoming an inter-racial society and moving beyond this kind of hate. But there is always a new victim to take the old victims place. No wonder all 3 of my adult kids no longer identify with a religious body. BTW We too are Jewish. Do the right thing, Gov. Lingle, and support what this country was supposerd to be about - equal justice under the law, liberty and justice for all. And freedom from religious tyranny All the religious opponents do is convince so many good youth that religion is a bad, if not horrible thing. Slavery was condoned as per the bible, Jesus own people were mass murdered by a catholic who learned his hatred of Jews growing up in very catholic Austria. A hatred spread by the catholic church of life. And 50 million died for this hatred and he Hitler - may his name be a curse forever - and his church has yet to excommunicate him. And its quite reasonable to assume, that like myself, Gov Lingle lost faily close relatives in the Holocaust. Yet we see outrageous comments from some orthodox Jews about gays. Proving once again that the bibleS have been used to hate and condemn, not love, since the dawn of civilization. Little different then the terrorism we struggle against that is promulgated by a bible called the Koran.

Editors' Choice

Connect with KHON2

Apple iPhone App Google Android App Other Phones E-mail Alerts Facebook Fan Page Twitter News Feed Send Photos and Videos Submit News Tips
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.

Click for the BBB Business Review of this Television Stations & Broadcast Companies in Honolulu HI      © 2012 New Vision Television |  Site Map |  Terms of Use |  Privacy Statement |  FCC Compliance |  Employment |  Advertise on KHON2 |  Contact Us